Yearly, the NBA ecosystem makes an attempt to assign some type of asterisk to that yr’s champion, and 2025 can be no totally different. This yr’s champion, the Oklahoma Metropolis Thunder, will face accusations that their title is tainted by Pacers star Tyrese Haliburton tearing his achilles tendon within the first quarter of Recreation 7, however chances are high that even with that context within the sport that actually determined the collection, it nonetheless gained’t be probably the most controversial championship in current NBA historical past.
That honor will (seemingly) all the time go to the Los Angeles Lakers in 2020, as many through the years have tried to name their NBA Bubble triumph “Mickey Mouse” and dismiss it as lower than an actual championship, a stance was solely emboldened by Thunder guard (and 2020 champion) Alex Caruso saying within the aftermath of Sunday’s OKC triumph that nobody may say that he didn’t have an actual ring anymore:
Now, anybody who watches the video clip can (in all probability) inform that Caruso was simply showcasing the identical signature dry wit he’s displayed all through his profession, however it didn’t cease the comment from creating headlines throughout the web, and sparking discourse throughout social media — as evidenced by what number of replies to the above tweet have been utilizing it as an excuse to dismiss the Lakers’ seventeenth title.
The subsequent day, Caruso felt that he needed to make clear that he was joking. And in a rarity for a star, you may inform this wasn’t a fastidiously crafted assertion ghostwritten by a public relations employees, as a result of he gave simply concerning the funniest excuse attainable:
He additionally could also be underselling it, as — on condition that as the one Thunder participant to have beforehand gained a title — he needed to train his younger teammates how one can open a champagne bottle. So it stands to motive he could have had a couple of sips of that as effectively, and hey, after a hard-fought, seven-game collection victory, who may blame him?
Nonetheless, whether or not Caruso is joking or not — and as somebody who lined virtually his complete journey from G League standout to final NBA function participant, I feel it’s pretty apparent he was — it’s additionally probably not debatable that the Lakers’ championship was totally different from another title in NBA historical past. Performed in a bubble at Disney World in Orlando, Florida, on the peak of the COVID-19 pandemic and after a multi-month layoff, it’s not even a debate that there has by no means been a championship run precisely prefer it.
However totally different doesn’t imply lesser. The playoffs weren’t going to be performed in residence arenas that yr, and even the 2021 postseason was performed in principally partially stuffed stadiums because of well being and security protocols. There was simply no situation the place the NBA was going to close down lengthy sufficient to have a playoffs precisely like all others in historical past.
The Lakers nonetheless gained the title, although, regardless of dropping out on the homecourt benefit they’d performed onerous all yr for, and amidst the identical circumstances that actually each single different crew needed to face. You’ll be able to say the cirumstances have been a bonus for them, however that ignores that each different crew had the identical “profit.” And when you’re saying that it’s a lesser title as a result of they acquired relaxation earlier than the run and didn’t have accidents, you’re saying that you simply’re extra interested by who can get the perfect random well being luck than who’s the perfect basketball crew that performed the perfect all yr.
Sure, the Lakers acquired a couple of months off and didn’t need to journey within the bubble, however the identical was true for all of their opponents. One may even argue that 2020 is absolutely the least gimmicky championship ever, on condition that the remainder meant practically each crew was at prime well being, nobody was fatigued from journey, and there have been no outdoors elements like raucous residence crowd, fast journey turnarounds and just one crew per sport having to take care of lodge beds.
We’ll by no means know for sure if the Lakers would have gained in any other case, however the identical is true for all champions: You’ll be able to solely play towards the opponents and circumstances in entrance of you. All we do know for positive now’s that Alex Caruso can win in both situation, and that perhaps the actual asterisk on the 2025 title is whether or not or not the Thunder would have gained it if the Lakers and Bulls weren’t each so silly.
